19 questions · 18 sources · 0 syntheses
Scientific Priority and Credit Disputes
Controversies over who deserves credit for a discovery.
Source-derived questions
Questions extracted from the papers in this topic, excluding the curated questions above.
- How did Bloch and Purcell arrive at the same discovery independently within months of each other?
- How did Cormack's mathematics anticipate Hounsfield's engineering without either knowing of the other?
- How did Irène Joliot-Curie's Nobel Prize connect to her mother Marie Curie's earlier work on radioactivity?
- How did Townes in New York and Basov and Prokhorov in Moscow arrive at working masers independently?
- How did two independent teams end up reporting the same unusual remedy?
- How was Franklin's Photograph 51 used by Watson and Crick without her knowledge?
- What caused the dispute between Waksman and Schatz over credit for discovering streptomycin?
- What does this episode reveal about how credentialed scepticism can delay scientific recognition?
- What happened in the credit dispute between Schatz and Waksman over the discovery of streptomycin?
- What priority dispute arose between Ross and the Italian research group, and why?
- What role did graduate student Harvey Fletcher play in the oil-drop experiment that went unacknowledged by the Nobel citation?
- Why did Banting give half his prize money to Best, and Macleod give half of his to Collip?
Show 7 more questions
- Why did Fleming receive most of the public credit even though Florey did much of the harder chemical work?
- Why did Henry Norris Russell initially pressure Payne to disavow her own correct conclusion?
- Why did Henry Norris Russell pressure Payne to downplay her own finding, and what happened when he later confirmed it himself?
- Why did the Nobel committee award the prize to Guillemin and Schally jointly rather than crediting one over the other?
- Why did the Nobel committee split the 1903 physics prize between Becquerel and the Curies rather than award it to one party?
- Why is the discovery sometimes called the Vine-Matthews-Morley hypothesis instead of just Vine-Matthews?
- Why was splitting the prize between Marconi and Braun considered diplomatically awkward?
Sources
- Cecilia Payne proves stars consist of hydrogen and helium
- Discovery of artificial radioactivity
- Discovery of streptomycin
- Henry Norris Russell confirms hydrogen as principal stellar constituent
- Ig Nobel Prize in Medicine
- Millikan oil-drop experiment begins measuring the electron charge
- Nobel Prize in Physics
- Nobel Prize in Physics
- Nobel Prize in Physics
- Nobel Prize in Physics
- Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine
- Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine